Please wait...
Please wait...
ums.org

    All comments by bill

    People Are Talking: UMS presents New York Philharmonic at Hill Auditorium:

  • Do you have any evidence to support your accusation that the NY Philharmonic felt they had to pander to Ann Arbor natives by playing “The Victors”? This would be a significant blow to their credibility, if true. The fact that you’ve failed to reply to Mr. Kondziolka’s point that the performance was initiated by a brass player who’s an UM alumni leads me to believe that it’s utterly baseless. If so, then your comments are libel and ought to be removed.

    The only thing embarrassing here is that this website is being used as a platform by Mr. Wiener to attack such respectable institutions as UMS and the NY Philharmonic. I know if I were Alan Gilbert, I’d think twice about coming back to Ann Arbor after reading such vitriol.

    In response to:
    "

    My mistake: I misread a prior post. As I said I wasn’t there. I’ve heard numerous musicians do “The Victors” after a performance – I’m not singling out the NHYPhil. For whatever reason they did it. I find it embarrassing for the reasons I’ve stated, no matter who plays it, why or when, at a classical music concert – or even at any concert here. It’s as if locals can’t bear to go unrecognized for a moment – and not even for the best of reasons. Does the “Victors” celebrate the UM world class medical and social research reputation? Its high academic and pedagogical standings in national college rankings? Its graduation rate? I’ll lighten up when not only world class performers but local music lovers stop turning every performance into an homage to the holy U of M football team. Next we’ll be standing for a moment of silence to celebrate our appetite for war.

    "
    by Paul Wiener

PERFORMANCES & EVENTS