Please wait...
Please wait...
ums.org

    All comments by Edie Ostapik

    People Are Talking: UMS presents Apollo’s Fire at Hill Auditorium:

  • It was also wonderful to hear the fully scored version of the sixth, complete with two viola da gambas! Though kind of sad, as those lovely instruments were on the wane.

    I totally agree with your point about the variety. Bach seems to be pushing the possibilities of key treble register and obvious solo instruments, for example, violin, recorder, trumpet, oboe. Featuring the viola is a bit unusual and creative, as in general the instrument floats between playing backup to the seconds or adding flavor to the basso continuo squad (notable exception is opening for the forth concerto.)

    I find it interesting that the only member of the continuo group to get true star treatment in the Brandenburgs is the harpsichord and recall reading (in extensive liner notes ages ago) that this was an innovation of the fifth concerto. During the concert, I found myself wondering, what about the cello? The part in the sixth concerto is pretty important with many vital phrases played by the cello, but that instrument never really gets the center stage in any of the concertos. If course, Bach more than makes up for this slight with the cello suites.

    In response to:
    "

    Apollo’s Fire were engagingly spirited (though far from note perfect) and I too enjoyed the director’s comments. How can one be bored with Bach in all his variety? I particularly liked the viola leads and clarity of textures in the great 6th concerto. I disliked the mannered pauses in the opening movements of the 3rd and 5th,, but other movements, e.g. the joyful last movement of the 5th, came off very well. The 2nd was much too fast, particularly for the valveless trumpet — it’s not just a sports event! Rod Little

    "
    by Rod Little
  • People Are Talking: UMS presents Apollo’s Fire at Hill Auditorium:

  • What a shame, Mr. Schiffer. To hear the complete cello suites in one or two sittings would be amazing. Something I have hoped for each season. A compromise: six concerts, each featuring a cello suite with complementary pieces, drawn even from outside of Bach or the baroque era.

    In response to:
    "

    I so understand your concern. This is the reason I never scheduled all Bach cello suites in one or two concerts. If I were in the audience I would want variety, and a program where the pieces relate, contrast, interact.
    However, in the case of some of the greatest composers, and for some listeners, the quality of the music and the variety within and between the works seem to justify such programs, which are entirely a modern or even post modern invention (the 18th century presented programs which were probably too fragmentary even for your taste).
    And frankly, don’t we get the same “monotony” in concerts by rock bands or jazz groups nowadays, who mainly play their own works?

    "
    by René Schiffer

PERFORMANCES & EVENTS