Spotlight on Volunteers in August

We simply couldn’t do business without the support of volunteers, who collectively offer over 45,000 hours each year volunteering for UMS programs.

Read the full story »
People Are Talking!

A place to talk to other people about what you think and see. Chat with patrons, staff, artists, and people around the globe.

UMS Lobby Events

Want to talk face-to-face? Here’s a chance to meet people like you and learn and chat about what you’ve seen and heard.

UMS Blog

Keep up-to-date with the latest happenings at UMS and throughout the arts scene in our weekly blog.

Video

NEW! Check out some of our latest video work – from special artist access to behind the scenes to upcoming shows.

Living Archive

A work in progress! Find details about our rich history – or help contribute your own story to the UMS legacy!

Home » People Are Talking!

People Are Talking About…The Rest is Noise

Alex Ross’ acclaimed book The Rest is Noise comes to life with help from pianist Ethan Iverson at Rackham Auditorium.  Iverson has described this performance as a “book recital” and we’re wondering what people think about that idea?

For more background on the project, don’t miss Alex Ross’ and Ethan Iverson’s blogs, plus our interview with Iverson about the project:

About Lisa Murray

Lisa Murray is the Manager of Foundation & Government Grants for UMS.

14 Comments »

  • Lisa Murray Lisa Murray says:

    Hi – Lisa Murray here from UMS. I'll be 'moderating' our online conversation about this performance, which starts in less than an hour. I'm told that I don't have to write clever things to be a blog moderator, nor do I need to be an expert on 20th century music (which I'm not) — my job is to faciliate conversation and respond to any questions. I did read Alex Ross's book some time ago and loved it, so I'm excited to see the performance and hear some of the music he wrote about so eloquently. Back after the concert…

  • Lisa Murray Lisa Murray says:

    Really enjoyed the 'book recital'! I will always think about Schoenberg now whenever I pick up a grapefruit in the market… Curious to hear what others thought of it.

  • Mary Matthews Mary Matthews says:

    Ross does write eloquently and knowledgeably, but he is disappointing on the stage. Where we were sitting, near the back, he was hard to hear, because he talks (actually, he was simply reading from his book) very fast, swallows his words, and tends to throw away his punch lines by lowering his voice and turning away from the microphone. The piano music was wonderful, and Ethan Iverson amazingly versatile, but I was hoping to learn more; what Ross read did not relate that precisely to what Iverson played. This was a curious hybrid, neither concert nor lecture. It would have been more enlightening to stay home and read Ross's book.
    This, is the first time I have been so disappointed by a UMS performance, and I've attended for years, so I feel a bit guilty for my comments!

    • Lisa Murray Lisa Murray says:

      Mary, no need to feel guilty — all comments are welcome, especially thoughtful ones like yours! I agree, Alex Ross did seem a little shy or nervous. Also, it was when I was reading this book that I thought for the first time about purchasing a Kindle-type product (still haven't done it though). I wanted to be able to read a passage, then click on a link and listen to the exact music he was describing right then and there. If I could do that, and if my Kindle-type product could somehow provide me with 24/7 access to Ethan Iverson's piano improvisations on demand, I would be set…

  • Pinar Pinar says:

    I had the same problem of not following the stories as good as I wanted to. I'm not quite sure how the stories could have been communicated better: maybe with a better sound system or maybe telling the stories in a more concise manner. I would love to read the book, though. The idea and performance was very unique and interesting.

  • Bob Kiningham Bob Kiningham says:

    We sat close to the front and could hear Alex fine, but I agree that he does not have a great stage presence. I have read the book, so it was a bit disappointing to have him just read excerpts. I enjoyed the piano selections – it would have been interesting to hear more about the specific unique musical elements of the pieces and how they reflected the composer's individual style and the changing styles of 20th century music. That being said, I still enjoyed the event and am glad I took the time to attend!

  • Sherry Root Sherry Root says:

    Somehow, with my limited knowledge of 20c. music,I waded through Alex Ross' book, so I was delighted to hear him in Ann Arbor. Our son is a contemporary composer, creating what often seems "noise." He led me to the book, and indeed I have learned. Music, as in all of life and art, evolves, and I want to be a part of the process. Ethan Iverson is amazingly versatile. Thank you for this lecture/concert. Sherry Root, member of UMS Choral Union.

  • Linnea Lannon Linnea Lannon says:

    My reaction was similar to several posters. We were right in front, so could hear Alex Ross without difficulty, but I was expecting more than just hearing excerpts from the book. Not knowing much about 20th Century music, I was actually hoping he would talk more about the structure various composers used, then have the pianist illustrate what he was talking about. I thought the pianist was great and though I'm glad I attended, I was hoping for something more.

  • dunrie dunrie says:

    I loved the YouTube video by Ethan Iverson ahead of the event.

    The concert was exactly as I expected – selections from the book and then selections from the composers. I agree that Alex Ross had less of a stage presence than an actor would have (read too fast, overly diffident), but I thought it was kind of sweet. Being a writer myself, I understand that shyness. I had heard the book on CD from the Ann Arbor District Library, and if you want to hear it read well, I highly recommend a listen!

    I also found that the concert healed an injury to my back. No joke.http://scientificink.com/blog/2010/04/27/music-an...

  • Jim Leija Jim Leija says:

    What a great comment! I think maybe in our next brochure we should say "UMS cures back pain!!" –Jim @ UMS

  • Dunrie Dunrie says:

    I loved the YouTube video by Ethan Iverson ahead of the event.
    The concert was exactly as I expected – selections from the book and then selections from the composers. I agree that Alex Ross had less of a stage presence than an actor would have (read too fast, overly diffident), but I thought it was kind of sweet. Being a writer myself, I understand that shyness. I had heard the book on CD from the Ann Arbor District Library, and if you want to hear it read well, I highly recommend a listen!
    I also found that the concert healed an injury to my back. No joke.http://scientificink.com/blog/2010/04/27/music-an...

  • Lisa Murray Lisa Murray says:

    Interesting to read everyone's comments so far — thanks for posting. It sounds like some people might have enjoyed something closer to an in-depth lecture/demonstration, while others may have been looking for more of a performance experience. What do you think about the general 'book recital' idea? Would you be interested in seeing more events like this one?

  • dunrie dunrie says:

    I would be interested in seeing more events like this. Knowing the event was coming spurred me to read the book, and that helped me enjoy the event even more!

  • [...] shoulder blade. Later that day, I attended a concert at Rackham Auditorium. It was a reading by Alex Ross of his book The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century, accompanied by Ethan Iverson on the piano. While I enjoyed the crisp and funny writing, I found [...]

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.